AHA News |  

Oral Arguments Presented in Massachusetts Case Challenging “Under God” in Pledge of Allegiance

For Immediate Release

Contact: Brian Magee, 202-238-9088 ext. 105
bmagee@americanhumanist.org

(Washington, DC, February 14, 2012)—Yesterday afternoon the American Humanist Association argued in Massachusetts Superior Court that the state’s constitutional equal rights amendment should bar the practice of public schools conducting a daily flag-salute exercise that utilizes the version of the Pledge of Allegiance that includes the phrase “under God.”

This case, Jane Doe, et. als. v. Acton-Boxborough Regional School District et al, is particularly unique and important because the state’s constitutional equal protection guarantees are the basis of the suit, not the Establishment Clause of the U.S. Constitution’s First Amendment. This same strategy could be replicated in other jurisdictions.

“The daily recitation in public schools of a pledge declaring that the nation is ‘under God’ is discriminatory toward atheists and humanists,” said David Niose, president of the American Humanist Association and lead attorney for the plaintiffs in the case. “No child should go to school each day to have the class declare that her religious beliefs are wrong in an exercise that portrays her and her family as less patriotic than believers.”

Currently, Massachusetts law requires public school teachers to begin each day with a classroom recitation of the Pledge for the purpose of instilling patriotism and love of country. On behalf of the plaintiffs, the American Humanist Association’s Appignani Humanist Legal Center is asking for a court declaration that daily recitation of the “under God” version of the pledge is discriminatory. They also seek a court order that other, nondiscriminatory means should be used to instill patriotism.

The plaintiffs are not trying to discontinue patriotic exercises, but seek only to make those exercises inclusive and nondiscriminatory. The federal government added “under God” to its wording of the Pledge in 1954, at the height of the McCarthy era during the Cold War, whereas before that the Pledge simply declared that the nation was “one nation indivisible.” Plaintiffs are requesting that this inclusive version be used once again in Massachusetts, and/or that other means of instilling patriotism be used, such as reading about important historical figures and events. The original version of the Pledge, written in 1892, is completely secular and inclusive of all Americans.

The suit was originally filed in November 2010. In denying the defendants’ earlier motion to dismiss, the judge on May 25, 2011 wrote in part: “The daily affirmation to children that America is ‘one nation under God’ cannot be characterized as just a meaningless ceremony, for in the context of daily public school recitation (accompanying the salute of the national flag) such a statement becomes the equivalent of official State doctrine – far from meaningless…”

The court took the motions for summary judgment under advisement and did not indicate when a ruling could be expected.

###

The American Humanist Association advocates for the rights and viewpoints of humanists. Founded in 1941 and headquartered in Washington, D.C., its work is extended through more than 100 local chapters and affiliates across America.  Humanism is a progressive philosophy of life that, without theism, affirms our responsibility to lead ethical lives of value to self and humanity.

The Appignani Humanist Legal Center is a project of the American Humanist Association that provides legal assistance to defend the constitutional rights of secular Americans by challenging violations of the separation of church and state guaranteed by the Establishment Clause and seeking equal rights for humanists, atheists and other freethinkers.

American Humanist Association

This week on the Humanist Hour Podcast, AHA Legal Director Dave Niose talks abou...

5 hours ago

American Humanist Association

Do you or your family have any holiday traditions?

7 hours ago

American Humanist Association

What are you thankful for?

9 hours ago

American Humanist Association

Yet again, Neil deGrasse Tyson breaks down a movie we love! Neil, your'e are su...

1 days ago

American Humanist Association

We all have a "dark side" but that doesn't have to be a bad thing. Psychologist...

1 days ago

American Humanist Association

UCoR proudly announces the official launch of the Rhode Island CoR with a bus ad...

1 days ago

American Humanist Association

It is wonderful to see so many skeptics, atheists, humanists, and non-theists co...

1 days ago

American Humanist Association

How the AHA and local Colorado humanists helped to defeat the anti-choice person...

2 days ago

American Humanist Association

Suspended for a week for defending evolution? That is a bit of an over-reaction...

2 days ago

American Humanist Association

What if you could win $1,000 for telling the world what is important to you? Al...

2 days ago

American Humanist Association

Fighting Back the Right: Reclaiming America from the Attack on Reason, the new b...

4 days ago

American Humanist Association

Things that make you go hmmm....

4 days ago

American Humanist Association

Here is a cool new Kickstarter campaign to create a children's book for non-bel...

5 days ago

American Humanist Association

AHA board member Howard Katz is at Skepticon representing! Make sure to stop by...

5 days ago

American Humanist Association

December 2nd is Giving Tuesday. This holiday season, while you are buying gifts...

5 days ago

American Humanist Association

Hey, It's our favorite science guy! Clay Farris Naff talks with past AHA humanis...

5 days ago

American Humanist Association

Who is ready for Skepticon 2014?! If you are attending the event, make sure to s...

6 days ago

American Humanist Association

Today is National Transgender Day of Remembrance. Today we remember transgenders...

6 days ago

American Humanist Association

Today the American Humanist Association’s Appignani Humanist Legal Center sent a...

6 days ago

American Humanist Association

Many people don't believe that a person can be good without a god. What are thos...

6 days ago

American Humanist Association

Yesterday, AHA's David Niose presented his argument that the phrase "under God"...

6 days ago

American Humanist Association

A Congressional hearing on religious accommodations in the armed services is hap...

7 days ago