Hnn | HNN Articles

Plan B: Empowering Girls and Upsetting Pundits

 

In a victory for the women’s right movement, Plan B will now be available over-the-counter for girls under 17 without parental permission. AHA Communications Intern Sam Mauceri examines the Religious Right’s unreasonable reaction to the good news.


Good news for humanists and the women’s rights movement: Plan B will soon be available to women and girls of all ages. The “morning-after pill,” which was previously unavailable to those under 17 without a prescription from a doctor and a government-issued ID, is expected to reduce the number of abortions in teenage girls and aid young victims of rape and incest with its wider reach. Not surprisingly, since the news of the upcoming availability of the pill hit the ears of conservatives, pundits and bloggers have responded with comments that range from vitriolic to misogynistic to just plain bizarre.

One of the strangest arguments in the current discussion was summarized by Laura Ingraham in an appearance on Fox & Friends. “It’s a good deal for pedophiles, a good deal for people who commit statutory rape against young girls.” Adding to that charming sound bite is Ingraham’s suggestion that parents will fall into a false sense of security, thinking that “my daughter or her boyfriend or her rapist can go out to a pharmacy and get a bunch of, you know, hormone pills to give to a little girl...”. Because what parent wouldn’t feel secure in the idea of a rapist procuring Plan B for a victim of sexual assault?

Anna Higgins of the Family Research Council constructs a similar hypothetical in which a predator supposedly drops $40-60 on Plan B preemptively, claiming that “removing doctors and parents from the equation will make it much easier for predators to conceal sexual abuse and to force the drug's use on minors.” While the scenario offered by Ingraham and Higgins is certainly not impossible, it is distracting from the intended purposes of the pill and, quite frankly,  entirely irrelevant. After all, previous to the recent expansion of access of Plan B, adult men were already able to purchase it without a prescription or an ID. Allowing young teenagers additional protection from unwanted pregnancy will not make this “good deal for pedophiles” scenario any more prevalent than it already is.

Another argument making the rounds is that of consequences. In his article “Should There Be a Morning After?” blogger Robert Katula insists that the pill “eliminates the life lesson that comes from living with the consequences of one’s action.” Similarly, in her aptly named “I Finally Agree With Obama,” Angye Morrison writes that she doesn’t “think a teenager should be able to get her hands on the morning-after pill, which takes away the consequences of behavior that should have consequences.”  Morrison utilizes typical slut-shaming rhetoric, confuses Plan B with an abortive pill, and trivializes the concerns and feelings of teenage girls in a failed attempt at identifying with them: “Can you say drama queen?” Meanwhile, Katula’s article simply asks the wrong question. After sexual activity, there is without a doubt a “morning after,” and to suggest that a woman or girl should not make decisions regarding her reproductive health during that time is to deny reality and to strip women of their agency in favor of teaching them a lesson. Never mind that that lesson would last the next 18 years of their lives, at the very least.

While the pundits and bloggers frame their arguments in terms of protecting young girls, don’t they actually accomplish the opposite? Ingraham’s claim that all-ages access to Plan B will “empower men who want to abuse women” misrepresents the intended and most prevalent use of the pill, while others complacently accept teenage pregnancies as consequences instead of aiming to help the young women in their lives. Their bizarre and unfounded arguments never cease to amaze. They never cease to hurt young women either.


Sam Mauceri, Communications InternSam Mauceri is the Summer 2013 Communications Intern for the American Humanist Association.

blog comments powered by Disqus

American Humanist Association

The Humanevangelist: Skyfall, Humanist Style by Clay Farris Naff. http://thehu...

2 days ago

American Humanist Association

Would you, or someone you know, be a good fit for the American Humanist Associat...

2 days ago

American Humanist Association

Here is an interesting letter to the editor of The Press Enterprise. http://www...

2 days ago

American Humanist Association

Happy 271st Birthday Thomas Jefferson! Read Jefferson's wall of separation lett...

3 days ago

American Humanist Association

Oh good so there are options... Happy Friday Everyone!! http://obscureinternet....

5 days ago

American Humanist Association

The Bible According to Thomas Jefferson. http://thehumanist.com/magazine/march...

5 days ago

American Humanist Association

We are getting ready! Are you? Register today! http://conference.americanhumani...

5 days ago

American Humanist Association

Inheriting the Wind by Daniel Thomas Moran! http://thehumanist.com/arts_enterta...

5 days ago

American Humanist Association

Throwback Thursday! What did the July/August, 1981 issue of the Humanist magazi...

6 days ago

American Humanist Association

Oh good! Now we can all relax... Science is here! Four Blood Moons: Total Lunar...

6 days ago

American Humanist Association

Check out this info-graph from the Public Religion Research Institute. http://...

6 days ago

American Humanist Association

Rules Are for Schmucks: House Rules. By Luis Granados http://thehumanist.com/ne...

6 days ago

American Humanist Association

Another installment of Carl Coon's A Short History of Evolution. This week's top...

7 days ago

American Humanist Association

AHA's Matthew Bulger reports from On The Hill. http://thehumanist.com/news/nati...

7 days ago

American Humanist Association

Check out the latest Humanist Hour Podcast with Guy P. Harrison on Skepticism an...

7 days ago

American Humanist Association

Check out Roy Speckhardt's new Huffpost Article "Why Population Dynamics Matter"...

7 days ago

American Humanist Association

Atheists Who Adopt: We're Raising Our Seven Kids, Four Through Adoption, to be F...

8 days ago

American Humanist Association

With the National Day of Reason fast approaching we need your help in getting me...

8 days ago

American Humanist Association

Check out this cool comic strip! Thanks Ayhan Bardakchiev for sharing. To view...

8 days ago

American Humanist Association

Matthew Bulger, AHA Legislative Associate, gives us his take on Noah. http://t...

8 days ago

American Humanist Association

The Ethical Dilemma: I Loved Annie Hall. Should I Hate Woody Allen? http://theh...

9 days ago

American Humanist Association

NEWS: Minnesota Lawmakers Introduce Bills To Allow Atheist Wedding Officiants....

9 days ago

American Humanist Association

Woo Hoo! Thank you to everyone who donated to the InStove campaign through Hum...

9 days ago