Hnn | HNN Articles

The Borrowed Argument Trap

 

COLUMN BY DOUG THOMAS

For HumanistNetworkNews.org
July 15, 2009

One of the basic concepts that my fellow teachers and I try to teach our students is the avoidance of borrowed arguments in their essays. A borrowed argument is the use of secondary sources as one's evidence without going back to primary sources to verify the truth of those secondary sources. I do wish other contemporaries would set better examples for those students.

From time to time, we all find ourselves trying to understand information that is not within our formal education information set. I do this all the time, convincing myself that I am justified because the skill sets involved in my North American History and Literature degree are research and communication. In theory anyway, those skill sets allow me to find accurate information about any subject and make a clear case for the ideas that I derive from it.

Every so often I need to remind myself to get back to primary source materials rather than just accept secondary source information as being true. Certainly secondary sources are more readily available and very useful to find a path to original information. They also contain the syntheses and extrapolations of people far more qualified than I in many subject areas.

However, the basis for these secondary sources must always be checked out and verified at least in part by getting to primary sources. The internet makes this at once easy, since one can get directly to many primary documents, and daunting, since one can be misled by claims of the authenticity of those documents.

Recently, a local philosophy professor, who must surely have learned this lesson at some point in his academic career, reduced his credibility by ignoring this simple idea. There is no question that he was operating well outside his natural skill set-abstract logic-when he decided to take on a subject based on climatology.

In his attempt to dismiss global warming he built an argument based on data that reveal an actual drop in temperature observed from satellites. His error was to accept an oil-fired economist as a valid secondary source for this information without checking out the primary source.

In this case, the economist erroneously treated the temperature data from the satellites as earth-surface data when, in fact, satellites gather temperature data from above the stratosphere. I was able to get to NASA's primary data easily enough on the Internet and verify this. The drop in temperature at the stratospheric level verifies the increase in insulation from increased greenhouse gases rather than refuting the general rise in surface temperatures. This simple informational gap led an otherwise erudite and intelligent individual to accept a completely wrong interpretation as fact.

Given that we are presented with so much interpretive information, we are also confronted with an increased need to get back to primary evidence as much as possible. Extrapolation and synthesis are useful tools, but only if there is primary evidence upon which to base them.

 

Doug Thomas is an English teacher and novelist, an agnostic member of SOFREE (Society of Ontario Freethinkers), and an active member of the Humanist Association of Canada. He is also Managing Editor of Canadian Freethinker.

blog comments powered by Disqus

American Humanist Association

We're happy to welcome a new chapter, Montgomery Humanists, to the American Huma...

5 days ago

American Humanist Association

This week on the Humanist Hour Podcast, Bo Bennett and Kim Ellington speak with...

5 days ago

American Humanist Association

As we have seen by the recent murders of three nonreligious bloggers—Ananta Bijo...

6 days ago

American Humanist Association

Jennifer Bardi, editor-in-chief of the Humanist magazine, recaps the AHA's 74th...

6 days ago

American Humanist Association

Prospective Student Webinar this Thursday! Considering the next class of The Hum...

6 days ago

American Humanist Association

Help the Louisville Atheists and Freethinkers represent humanists at this year's...

7 days ago

American Humanist Association

Humanist Pioneer Awardee Isaiah Smith, stands up for separation of church and st...

7 days ago

American Humanist Association

A South Carolina court has ruled that prayer in public school graduations doesn'...

7 days ago

American Humanist Association

Right-wing media loves terrorism stories, so how did they all manage to miss thi...

7 days ago

American Humanist Association

Omaha Metro Area Humanist Association, a chapter of AHA, is participating in Oma...

7 days ago

American Humanist Association

This week on the Humanist, Becky Garrison sits down with Quiet Company's Taylor...

8 days ago

American Humanist Association

Don't miss the Humanist "Ask Me Anything" session with Kristin Wintermute, Execu...

8 days ago

American Humanist Association

We love to see our fellow free-thinkers doing what they can to help out humanity...

8 days ago

American Humanist Association

With the number of Christians declining and the unaffiliated rising in the US, w...

8 days ago

American Humanist Association

Ethical Dilemma: How much would you change for your significant other's beliefs?

10 days ago

American Humanist Association

Happy Friday Everyone!

11 days ago

American Humanist Association

We're happy to welcome a new chapter, Palm Beach Humanists, to the American Huma...

11 days ago

American Humanist Association

Bob Diven, AHA celebrant in New Mexico, recently participated in a debate about...

11 days ago

American Humanist Association

Washington DC does something right, and we aren't talking about the feds!

12 days ago

American Humanist Association

On May 13, the AHA joined other members of the National Coalition for Public Edu...

12 days ago

American Humanist Association

Ethical Dilemma: What to do about a rude house guest. Tell us your experience w...

12 days ago

American Humanist Association

Don't miss the Humanist Institute's upcoming "Ask Me Anything" session with Kris...

13 days ago

American Humanist Association

On this week's episode of the Humanist Hour Podcast, Bo Bennett interviews singe...

13 days ago

American Humanist Association

A very happy 127th birthday to Inge Lehmann, the Danish seismologist and geophys...

13 days ago

American Humanist Association

Do community events like "Draw Mohammad" contests promote freedom of speech or j...

13 days ago